PRAGOTI

The long reply of Mr. Shamsher Singh (a well-wisher of the Left movement and former SFI member but not from JNU) is very arrogant write up where he is dictating to all the signatories to know their limits. He is even questioning the right of the signatories which mean that he has his definition of 'rights' and not willing to accept anything beyond that. This is very dictatorial attitude and the same is reflected in the decision of All India SFI where they failed to counter the arguments raised by JNU SFI on the question of support of CPIM to Mr. Pranab Mukerjee. A very genuine question of JNU SFI was projected as a conspiracy ( as per the reference of Mr. Shamsheer Singh - http://www.pragoti.in/node/4731 ). To a utmost shock All India SFI is yet to take a position on question raised by JNU SFI. Let them first clarify their position on the support of Pranab Mukerjee There is issue of unit conference been raised by Mr. Shamsheer. I am sure that All India SFI was also aware of fact that JNU Unit is not having its unit conferences. My question is what action they had initiated in last three years against the JNU unit for not conveying the unit conference. In this regard All- India SFI is equally responsible for this and now they are shifting entire blame on JNU SFI. When there was so much of persisting problems in JNU SFI and All India SFI ignored it for so many years i think action should immediately be taken against them for complete ignorance and not fulfilling their duties. To my best knowledge All India SFI also had a national convention in JNU. This convention was organized by the active involvement of JNU SFI. If there was so much of problems in JNU why does the All India SFI opted for JNU as a venue? In last i must appeal to Mr. Shamsheer Singh to respect the democratic rights of the signatories and try to understand the issue in totality. Today what is the reason for decline of left in India? What wedge left has created by supporting Pranab Mukerjee (Mamta also supported him). Let me also put a point for mr. Shasheer Singh that CPI has also not support Pranab Mukerjee and raised certain issues regarding the support of CPI(M), as per the logic of All India SFI we must also dissolve left front (because CPI is a part of it). The decision of All India SFI is completely irrational and devoid of any substantial reasoning. I think that Mr. Shasmeer should adopt a democratic and left position and should support the issue raised by signatories. Ramesh Chandra (also a well-wisher of the Left movement and former SFI member but not from JNU)